Should I try to become a thought leader?
No. Thought leadership is a consequence of doing the work and making your thinking visible, not a content strategy you can start with.
No. Thought leadership is what happens after you do the work and make your thinking visible. If you chase the label, you get the surface of conviction without the evidence behind it. It is a consequence, not a content strategy.
I think trying to become a thought leader is one of the fastest ways to start producing absolute nonsense. Somehow thought leadership became a type of LinkedIn post: a bold statement, a framework and a slightly smug conclusion. Surely the first requirement is having a thought.
Why does trying to look like a thought leader backfire?
We see established people using frameworks, strong opinions and confident language. What we do not see is the years, the hundreds of decisions, the failures and the repetition underneath.
So we copy the surface signals of original thinking. You can copy the format of conviction without earning the conviction, and the result sounds less like original thinking, not more. Confidence with nothing underneath it reads as a performance, because that is what it is.
What has AI changed about this?
Ask AI for ten contrarian opinions and you have ten thought leadership posts in seconds. The unpopular opinion, the hot take, the prediction and the named framework are all cheap to produce now.
That takes the scarcity out of the look of original thinking. It makes actual experience worth more, because experience is the one thing that cannot be produced in seconds.
Where do real ideas come from?
Real ideas often start small. Something is weird. You do not think something is true. You keep seeing the same thing. You used to believe one thing and now you do not.
That is noticing before opinion. The thought appears because something in reality pushed against what you expected, and that is the only kind worth publishing.
What gives an opinion its weight?
Evidence. Saying that personalised outreach is overrated is a hot take. Having stopped personalising and seen what happened is a different thing.
I sent LinkedIn messages to people I had never met with no personalisation at all, and I got better results than when I spent loads of time building rapport first. I was scared to stop at first, because I thought people would not reply. The opinion carries weight because reality pushed against it.
Do I have to disagree with everyone?
No. Consensus is sometimes right, and contrarianism can become another performance. The goal is not to disagree. It is to stop outsourcing agreement.
Say the conclusion you genuinely reached, whether it is spicy or boring.
How does a worldview build up?
Through repetition. After enough pieces, people should be able to predict how I will think about a problem. That is positioning through a body of thought rather than a tagline.
I could make one video about AI, another about how I build lead magnets, another about mindset and another about the tools I use. Not every one of them had to be about business directly.
Once someone has been through ten of them, they have a full idea of my worldview. That is why people choose to work with me, and it has little to do with having the best offer.
A piece does not need to be a tutorial to add to that body of work. I cover that in does every post have to be useful.
What can I do instead for a week?
Stop asking AI for topics. Capture four things from your own work:
- One thing you changed your mind about.
- One problem you keep seeing in client work.
- One thing you disagree with because of your experience.
- One surprising result.
Use the strongest. Those four come from work you have actually done, so they cannot be generated for you in seconds, and that is the point of the week.
When does thought leadership actually happen?
You do not become a thought leader because LinkedIn starts calling you one. You become one because enough people repeatedly encounter the way you think and decide it helps them think better.
How that body of thought turns into clear positioning is covered in personal-brand positioning. Until then, stop trying to be a thought leader. Have a thought.
KnownTrustedBought
Join my daily email